What If The Other Party Changes Their Story After An Accident?

In the moments following a car crash, or any type of accident, people involved often provide immediate accounts of what happened. These statements, whether shared with police, insurance adjusters, or even other drivers, can play a big role in determining fault and shaping the direction of a personal injury claim. But what happens when the other party changes their story later on?

Unfortunately, it’s not uncommon for someone to shift their narrative once they realize they may be held financially or legally responsible. If you’re in this situation, connect with a Miami personal injury lawyer to talk through your rights and learn about the steps you need to take in order to protect yourself from false or misleading claims.

Why People Change Their Story

There are several reasons someone might alter their account after an accident.

• Fear of liability. Once they understand the consequences, such as higher insurance premiums, legal fees, or a potential lawsuit, they may try to minimize their role.
• Pressure from insurance companies. Some insurers coach policyholders to be cautious with their words or even dispute initial statements if it helps avoid paying a claim.
• Lack of clarity or memory. A person might genuinely misremember details or believe something different happened after reviewing the scene or speaking with others.
• Deliberate deception. Sadly, some people intentionally lie in hopes of avoiding blame or shifting responsibility onto you.

If you notice that the other party is now telling a different version of events, don’t panic, but act quickly and carefully. For one, stick to the facts. Don’t try to argue or convince the other person on your own. Simply rely on the facts of what happened and share your version with your attorney and insurance company.

Evidence is also key. Photos, videos, and witness statements from the scene can be powerful proof that supports your version of events. The sooner you gather these, the better. Get a copy of police reports, too. Officers often write down statements made at the scene. If the other party initially admitted fault, it might be recorded in the report, which could be valuable later on.

Protecting Yourself From False Claims

The best defense is preparation. Never admit fault at the scene, and avoid making statements that could be misunderstood. You will also want to document everything you can. Keep track of all conversations and correspondence related to the incident. This includes emails, texts, and phone call summaries.

Should another party change their story, you still have options. Truth and evidence are powerful tools, especially when guided through the process by a knowledgeable Miami personal injury lawyer. Attorneys know how to identify inconsistencies and hold others accountable for dishonest statements.

Don’t let falsehoods undermine your claim. Take action, protect your rights, and speak with a trusted injury attorney who can help set the record straight.

Do you need legal support? There are ways to fortify your position, even when someone else is lying. Talk to the attorneys at Spencer Morgan Law to learn more. Call 305-423-3800 to book a confidential consultation.